Before and After the Storm: Rebuilding Frenchman’s Reef Resort

How an existing property assessment became the foundation for a comprehensive hurricane response, forensic investigation, and reconstruction effort.

In 2017, Construction Consulting Associates (CCA), now part of Aperture, was engaged to evaluate the condition of Frenchman’s Reef Resort, an expansive oceanfront property in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands. What began as a property assessment soon evolved into a comprehensive Frenchman’s Reef restoration effort following the devastation caused by Hurricanes Irma and Maria.

The resort included multiple buildings, more than 400 guestrooms, restaurants, meeting and ballroom spaces, and extensive supporting infrastructure. Its operations depended on complex systems, including onsite power generation, sewage treatment, and water treatment facilities.

The initial assignment was a property-wide condition assessment.

Shortly afterward, Hurricanes Irma and Maria struck the island, causing widespread devastation and fundamentally changing the scope of the team’s involvement.

From assessment to disaster response

The earlier property assessment gave the team a valuable starting point for understanding conditions at the resort before the hurricanes.

Following the storms, CCA mobilized to evaluate the damage and assist the property owner, DiamondRock Hospitality, and its representatives.

The investigation involved multiple disciplines and building systems, including roofing, façades, stucco and EIFS, stone masonry, windows and doors, structural steel, waterproofing, and mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and fire protection systems.

The team also evaluated site conditions, hardscaping, and other civil and engineering components throughout the property.

Separating the damage

With two major hurricanes striking in close succession, determining which storm caused specific damage was an important part of the investigation.

CCA conducted damage assessments, moisture mapping, and remediation reviews. The team examined the causes of observed damage and evaluated building code requirements that could affect repair and reconstruction.

These findings informed repair scopes and cost estimates while supporting the owner’s property insurance claim.

The work required an understanding of how the resort’s many interconnected building systems had been affected and what would be necessary to restore them.

Frenchman’s Reef Restoration and Reconstruction

CCA’s role extended beyond forensic investigation.

As stabilization and reconstruction efforts progressed, the team assisted with design development, permitting, and coordination of the architectural and engineering design team.

CCA also provided construction management and owner’s representative services, helping coordinate the complex process of repairing and rebuilding a large hospitality property following a major disaster.

The assignment brought together forensic engineering, building code analysis, design coordination, and construction management within a single project.

From investigation to resolution

CCA’s forensic findings and technical analysis supported the owner’s insurance claim and subsequent litigation efforts.

Members of the project team provided deposition testimony as part of the legal proceedings. The dispute ultimately concluded with a mutually acceptable insurance settlement before trial.

The Frenchman’s Reef project illustrates the value of integrating property assessment, forensic investigation, and reconstruction expertise. What began as an evaluation of an existing resort evolved into a comprehensive response to catastrophic damage, supporting the owner through investigation, insurance claim resolution, and the rebuilding process.